26 December 2003
It seems to me that, above all people on the earth, Christians should be the most intelligent and most rational about their existence. After all, most other people’s belief systems are bound to their own ideas of reality - in other words, they are generally bound to the culture of day. And the culture of today is exceedingly irrational and relativistic. Most people today have given into despair because they have no moral basis for any belief, or have a belief which is inconsistent at best and irrational at worst. Irrationality rules the world.
Christians, having a basic structure for belief (the argument for whether a faith based structure is rational or not can be left for another day), should be the most rational. After all, they have a coherent basis from which to work - they can seek to understand its intricacies and depth, and attempt to play it out in their lives. Because they have a foundation, Christians can study and know it and incorporate into their lives. Is their anything more real than a person who truly lives out his or her beliefs? Isn’t moral consistency the logical result of a rational belief system?
I say Christians should be the most rational; I’m referring to their understanding of what they believe, their ability to live it out in their lives, and their ability to communicate it to others. There is something there to know and understand, unlike those who are knowingly or unknowingly relativists. For that reason, Christians should be able to know more and go deeper than any others.
I don’t think that’s the case. Most Christians I know are as irrational as the rest of the world and nearly as relativistic. It’s as if, in this day and age, there is certain disrespect for those who want consistency and truth. And there is, most certainly disrespect for those who point out inconsistency in others. It’s troublesome. Rational thought will not save us; neither will moral consistency. Yet they should be a result of the Christian life.
EDIT:
I feel obligated to note that a rational belief system based on worship of God should be rational in relationship with God. In other words, if you believe in a God who knows all - and he instructs you to sell your house and move across the country, it’s perfectly logical that you obey and do so. Yet others would point out that you have a nice house and a good job; to them, you’re being irrational. True rationality is based on whether it (faith) is based on something true.